CMS resources
CMS comparison hub
Back to CMS comparison hub

Why SharePoint falls short as a CMS for enterprise content management

man working with a Windows laptop on sofa

In the quest for a robust enterprise content management system, many organizations turn to SharePoint for its document management capabilities. However, as businesses demand more dynamic solutions, SharePoint often reveals its limitations. Despite being a powerful tool for document storage, it lacks the flexibility and integration needed for comprehensive content management.

Microsoft's SharePoint has long been a popular choice for document management within the enterprise, particularly for organizations deeply invested in the Microsoft ecosystem. However, as businesses pivot toward more advanced and integrated digital content strategies, SharePoint often struggles to meet the requirements of a modern content management system (CMS). For organizations seeking a robust alternative to SharePoint, Brightspot CMS emerges as the superior choice with its flexible architecture, advanced capabilities and seamless integration with various digital tools.

This article explores the limitations of SharePoint as a CMS and highlights why Brightspot CMS is a future-ready solution for enterprise content needs.

SharePoint as a CMS: Document management vs. content management

SharePoint excels at document storage, file sharing and collaboration — functions it was originally designed to perform. Its integration with tools like Microsoft Office makes it invaluable for managing documents in teams and workflows. However, SharePoint as a CMS presents challenges, particularly for enterprises with diverse digital needs. Here’s why:

  • Limited content management features: SharePoint lacks robust features for managing dynamic content like blogs, multimedia galleries and e-commerce catalogs.
  • Rigid architecture: SharePoint often requires heavy customization to support content publishing workflows or multiple sites.
  • Insufficient multi-channel support: Delivering consistent, engaging experiences across websites, apps and other digital channels is cumbersome with SharePoint.
  • Complexity and maintenance: Using SharePoint for advanced content management typically demands extensive IT resources, making it less efficient for non-technical users.

Enterprises using SharePoint as a CMS often face scalability roadblocks and reduced agility — two critical factors for success in today’s digital-first business environment.

Why Brightspot CMS is the ideal alternative to SharePoint

Brightspot CMS is designed to address the exact challenges that limit SharePoint as a CMS, offering a modern, adaptable platform for enterprise content management. Below are the key areas where Brightspot outshines SharePoint:

#1 - Flexibility for diverse content needs
Unlike SharePoint, Brightspot CMS is built with flexibility at its core. It provides an intuitive interface for managing all content types, from simple text-based articles to complex multimedia libraries. Brightspot supports:

  • Rich multimedia experiences with native video and image management
  • Multisite management for organizations running multiple brands or regions
  • Quick adaptability for different industries, from news and publishing to e-commerce

With Brightspot, businesses can manage content workflows seamlessly without needing extensive customizations or plug-ins, making it a hassle-free alternative to SharePoint.

#2 - Streamlined workflows and collaboration

Brightspot CMS offers advanced workflows that allow teams to streamline the entire content lifecycle. Whether your organization requires:

  • Role-based approvals
  • Complex multi-departmental collaboration
  • Content scheduling and versioning

Brightspot supports these needs out of the box, enabling teams to maintain efficiency and accuracy. While SharePoint’s workflows are primarily geared toward document approvals, Brightspot’s workflow capabilities extend far beyond, empowering enterprises to tailor workflows to their specific requirements.

#3 - Enhanced personalization and engagement

In the age of hyper-personalization, delivering tailored content to different audience segments is crucial. Brightspot’s built-in AI and machine learning capabilities allow organizations to:

  • Automate content recommendations based on user behavior
  • Deliver dynamic, personalized experiences across multiple channels
  • Adapt content strategies in real time

SharePoint as a CMS falls short here, as it lacks robust personalization tools, leaving businesses with generic and static digital experiences.

#4 - Seamless integration across the digital ecosystem

While SharePoint integrates well within Microsoft’s suite of tools, its support for third-party integrations is limited. Brightspot CMS takes an API-first approach, enabling seamless integration with:

Analytics platforms, e-commerce platforms and more
This extensive integration capability allows enterprises to build a cohesive digital ecosystem, ensuring smooth data flow and operational efficiency.

#5 - Scalability for enterprise growth

SharePoint FAQs

What is SharePoint?

If you’re looking for a content management system with enterprise-level features and functionality, you may have considered SharePoint as a potential solution.

Launched in 2001, Microsoft SharePoint is a web-based collaboration and document management system. Organizations can install, deploy and manage SharePoint Server on-premises or with an Office 365 Enterprise subscription. Businesses may also use SharePoint within Microsoft 365. With this Microsoft-hosted, cloud-based service, you can subscribe to a Microsoft 365 plan or the standalone SharePoint Online service.

SharePoint is often called the “Swiss Army knife” of IT teams because it can be used to create websites, store information and much more.

Is SharePoint a content management system?

Yes, SharePoint can function as a content management system (CMS), but it is primarily designed for document management and collaboration within the Microsoft ecosystem. While it does have CMS capabilities, particularly for managing and organizing documents, intranets and some web content, SharePoint is not a full-featured CMS in the way that platforms like Brightspot or WordPress are.

SharePoint excels at document management, version control, workflows and integration with Microsoft Office products, making it ideal for organizations that prioritize internal collaboration and file sharing. However, its flexibility and usability as a comprehensive CMS — especially for managing diverse types of web content, delivering dynamic digital experiences and integrating with non-Microsoft tools — are limited compared to more specialized CMS platforms.

For businesses seeking advanced web content management, scalability, and integration with a wider range of digital tools, SharePoint may not meet all needs, and other CMS solutions like Brightspot are often better suited for those demands.

Brightspot’s cloud-first, modular architecture ensures that enterprises can scale their content operations effortlessly. Whether managing a single microsite or a global network of hundreds of sites, Brightspot handles growth with ease. In contrast, SharePoint’s scalability often requires significant IT investment and on-premises infrastructure adjustments, making it less cost-effective as businesses expand.

Choosing Brightspot CMS as your alternative to SharePoint

For enterprises evaluating SharePoint as a CMS, it’s essential to understand its limitations in delivering a modern, scalable content management solution. While SharePoint is a reliable tool for document collaboration, its inflexibility and lack of advanced features make it less suitable for organizations aiming to drive digital transformation.

Brightspot CMS offers:

  • A purpose-built platform for enterprise content management
  • Out-of-the-box workflows and personalization tools
  • Seamless integration across diverse tools and platforms
  • Superior scalability to meet the demands of growing businesses

By choosing Brightspot CMS as an alternative to SharePoint, enterprises unlock a future-ready solution designed to enhance efficiency, improve customer engagement and drive business success.

Share
Alistair Wearmouth
About the Author
Alistair Wearmouth is a content director with Brightspot, where he writes about our customers and the technology behind our award-winning CMS. He also supports various customer accounts with their content strategy and publishing needs. With over two decades of experience in digital content and product management, Alistair has helped lead implementation and development for homegrown as well as off-the-shelf CMS solutions at companies including USA Today, Orbitz and National Geographic.

More from Brightspot

Related resources

Vodafone New Zealand turned to Brightspot to help migrate from its legacy Drupal CMS to a dynamic content platform that would allow the telecommunications leader to deliver a transformative customer and corporate experience.
Digital content governance is the system or set of guidelines for how content gets created and published. From the chief product officer to the managing editor, digital and editorial leads alike can benefit from strong content governance through a unified content management system (CMS).
Global research firm Forrester says, "Agile CMS seeks to enable collaborative, iterative approaches to content and experiences that satisfy both sides of the house." We think Brightspot has embodied all these things for over a decade long before the firm coined the term in 2021 as part of its Forrester Wave evaluation of agile CMSs.
A content management system can be a major conduit to accomplishing time and cost savings. Brightspot allows brands to launch a fully functional digital experience at astonishing speed with significant cost savings.
From fostering meaningful connections to presenting a personalized experience, here are important steps to consider when building your next-generation intranet.
Whether you're creating an intranet from scratch or transforming a stagnant one, follow this six-step plan to get started in the most timely, cost-effective and efficient way possible.
Let us give you a demo
Hear how Brightspot can turn your digital strategy goals into a reality and see how the lives of your content creators and developers will be changed using our platform.


Request Demo