·¬ÇÑÉçÇø

CMS resources
CMS comparison hub
Brightspot vs. WordPress VIP
Back to Brightspot vs. WordPress VIP

Choosing the right CMS: WordPress VIP vs. Brightspot

graphic depicting differences between Brightspot CMS and WordPress VIP

With thousands of CMS options on the market, choosing the right CMS can be a daunting prospect. Here, we take a side-by-side look at Brightspot and WordPress VIP to help identify if Brightspot is the right CMS choice for your organization.

When choosing a new content management system (CMS), organizations face a long list of vendors, each offering different value propositions. With hundreds of CMS platforms available, narrowing down your options can be overwhelming. This article provides a side-by-side comparison of WordPress VIP and Brightspot to help you find the best fit for your organization in 2024.

Organizations often begin their search with familiar names like WordPress. While WordPress remains a popular choice for many, emerging solutions like Brightspot can offer greater flexibility, efficiency and scalability — especially in an enterprise environment. This article compares WordPress VIP, the enterprise-level offering of WordPress, with Brightspot to help you make an informed decision.

Alistair Wearmouth
By Alistair Wearmouth
October 28, 2024
A look at why enterprises are rethinking WordPress as their CMS of choice after its clash with hosting provider WP Engine.
4 Min Read

What is WordPress VIP?

WordPress VIP is a premium service layer built on top of the open-source WordPress CMS. It’s aimed at larger enterprises seeking better performance, enhanced security and scalability. However, despite these added services, the core of WordPress VIP still relies heavily on WordPress's basic architecture, which can present limitations in modern content strategies.

While WordPress VIP handles cloud hosting, security updates and code reviews, companies looking for more out-of-the-box functionality often need to heavily customize the platform, leading to longer project timelines and higher costs.

WordPress VIP still requires multiple vendors

One of the key drawbacks of WordPress VIP is its reliance on third-party providers for essential capabilities like themes, plugins and integrations. While Brightspot provides an all-in-one solution, WordPress VIP typically requires a combination of external vendors, which increases costs and introduces more complexity to projects.

As of 2024, a typical WordPress VIP engagement can cost anywhere from $7,000 to $30,000 a month — before factoring in the cost of third-party services, which can add even more to your budget. In contrast, Brightspot offers many core capabilities directly within its platform, reducing the need for external vendors.

Drawbacks of using open-source CMS software like WordPress vs. proprietary solutions like Brightspot

1. Security concerns

Open-source CMS platforms, including WordPress, are highly customizable but come with significant security challenges. Being open-source means the code is available to everyone, making it easier for attackers to find and exploit vulnerabilities.

  • Frequent security patches: WordPress requires regular updates and security patches, especially because third-party plugins are often points of vulnerability. Managing these updates can be time-consuming and, if overlooked, expose your site to risks.
  • Plugin vulnerabilities: WordPress sites often rely on a large number of third-party plugins, each introducing a new security risk. Many plugins are developed by independent contributors and may not be regularly updated or vetted for security.
Tip
Proprietary platforms like Brightspot are developed and maintained by a dedicated team with a focus on security. Brightspot comes with enterprise-level security features built in, reducing the need for constant monitoring, updating and patching of external components.

2. Complexity and maintenance

Open-source platforms are appealing due to their flexibility, but this flexibility comes at a cost.

  • Ongoing maintenance: WordPress users are responsible for the maintenance of their sites, including managing updates, plug-in compatibility and performance issues. As your site grows and you add more plug-ins, managing these elements becomes increasingly complex.
  • Fragmentation: The WordPress ecosystem is vast, and many third-party solutions may not integrate seamlessly. This can lead to compatibility issues, especially when plug-ins or themes come from different providers with different update schedules.
Tip
Brightspot, as a proprietary CMS, offers a cohesive, all-in-one platform with built-in features that don’t rely on external providers. This reduces maintenance complexity and ensures smoother performance and easier updates.

3. Scalability challenges

While WordPress is highly customizable, scaling it for large, complex enterprise environments often requires significant customization, which can be resource-intensive.

  • Third-party dependencies: To scale WordPress, enterprises often rely on external vendors and developers to manage key functionalities like content types, performance optimization and multisite management. This creates dependencies that can slow down project timelines and drive up costs.
  • Performance issues: As an open-source platform, WordPress can struggle with performance as a site grows. When too many plug-ins are used, performance can degrade, requiring custom development and technical expertise to tune.
Tip
Brightspot is designed for scalability, supporting large-scale operations, multisite environments and global enterprises out of the box without extensive third-party customization.

4. Support and accountability

In the open-source world, community support is often the primary resource for troubleshooting. This can work for small sites but becomes a challenge for enterprise users who require fast, reliable support.

  • Limited accountability: When problems arise in WordPress, especially with third-party plug-ins or themes, it can be difficult to find accountable support. While WordPress VIP offers some support services, they may not cover the third-party components your site depends on.
Tip
Brightspot provides dedicated enterprise-level support, offering a single point of contact and clear accountability. With Brightspot, you work directly with the platform's creators, ensuring that any issues are resolved quickly without having to coordinate across multiple vendors.

5. Customization complexity

WordPress is known for its flexibility, but deep customization often requires extensive development work.

  • Code bloat and conflicts: Extensive customization in WordPress can lead to code bloat as multiple plug-ins and custom solutions are layered on top of the base CMS. This can cause conflicts between plug-ins and lead to a slow or unstable website, especially if plug-ins are not properly maintained.
Tip
Brightspot offers deep customization within a modular architecture, allowing for flexibility without the need for extensive plug-ins. This ensures that customizations are tightly integrated and optimized for performance, reducing the risk of conflicts.

6. Total cost of ownership (TCO)

Open-source platforms like WordPress may seem cost-effective at first because they are free to use. However, for enterprise applications, the total cost of ownership can escalate quickly.

  • Hidden costs: Enterprises often need to invest heavily in third-party plug-ins, custom development, security management and ongoing maintenance to get WordPress to function at an enterprise level. The time and resources required to manage a WordPress site often lead to higher long-term costs.
Tip
Brightspot, while requiring an upfront investment, offers an all-in-one solution that eliminates the need for additional third-party vendors, security measures and custom development. This lowers the total cost of ownership over time, making it a more efficient and cost-effective choice for enterprises.

WordPress sites often rely on a large number of third-party plug-ins, each introducing a new security risk. Many plug-ins are developed by independent contributors and may not be regularly updated or vetted for security.

In contrast, proprietary platforms like Brightspot are developed and maintained by a dedicated team with a focus on security. Brightspot comes with enterprise-level security features built in, reducing the need for constant monitoring, updating and patching of external components.

5 ways Brightspot outshines WordPress VIP

  1. Fewer roadblocks with themes and customizations: WordPress VIP continues to require users to rely on third-party vendors to implement and customize themes. The need for frequent external collaboration can slow down your projects, especially when even minor changes require code reviews and coordination across teams. Brightspot, on the other hand, provides out-of-the-box themes that are fully customizable within the CMS — no additional fees or complex third-party arrangements needed.
  2. Streamlined integrations: The fragmented nature of WordPress VIP integrations remains a common pain point. With thousands of plugins available, selecting and managing them requires careful vetting. You’ll often need outside developers to handle integration, which adds cost and time. With Brightspot, most critical integrations are built in, and the platform is designed to let users configure them with ease — no coding required. This streamlines your workflows and minimizes reliance on multiple vendors.
  3. Content types and flexibility: WordPress VIP still lacks native support for advanced content modeling, requiring the use of plugins or custom development. As brands continue to embrace more varied and multimedia-driven content types, this gap becomes more pronounced. Brightspot, in contrast, provides a rich set of pre-built content types, from image galleries to live blogs, that users can easily extend, reducing the need for third-party customization.
  4. True multisite capabilities: Today, multisite capabilities are more crucial than ever as global enterprises manage multiple brands across regions. WordPress VIP still limits users to five sites per engagement, with additional charges for each extra site. This can quickly escalate costs for growing businesses. Brightspot allows for the management of hundreds of sites with seamless content sharing and workflow management across them, making it ideal for multinational enterprises.
  5. Modern architectures like headless CMS: The demand for headless CMS solutions and modular content architecture has grown significantly, yet WordPress VIP remains limited in its capacity to support these practices natively. While workarounds exist, they require significant development effort and add operational complexity. Brightspot, on the other hand, is designed with headless and modular content capabilities from the start, enabling teams to implement modern architectures quickly and efficiently.

Security concerns with WordPress VIP

One of the biggest challenges with using WordPress VIP in 2024 is its reliance on an open-source core and third-party plugins, which can introduce vulnerabilities. While WordPress VIP does offer enhanced security services — such as monitoring, patching and updating — its open-source architecture means that you’re inherently exposed to risks associated with widely used plugins.

  1. Plugin vulnerabilities: With over 50,000 plugins in the WordPress ecosystem, security risks can arise if these plugins are not properly maintained or patched. Even when using WordPress VIP, companies remain responsible for ensuring their third-party plugins are up to date. If a plugin contains a vulnerability, it can serve as a gateway for attacks, leaving your site and sensitive data at risk. Organizations with complex plugin stacks face the added challenge of tracking multiple updates and patches across providers.
  2. Frequent patching: Open-source platforms like WordPress require frequent security updates, and while WordPress VIP handles this process for the core CMS, plugin security is often left in the hands of external developers. The need to constantly monitor and patch plugins can result in delays and increased exposure to security breaches, as vulnerabilities in widely used plugins can quickly become targets for hackers.
  3. Risk of widespread attacks: WordPress’s popularity makes it a larger target for attackers. According to recent data, WordPress sites are frequently subjected to brute force attacks, malware injections and cross-site scripting (XSS) attacks. Even with the additional security layers WordPress VIP provides, the inherent risks of the underlying platform persist, especially for organizations handling sensitive information or large-scale operations.

Why Brightspot provides stronger security for enterprise-grade content management

Unlike WordPress VIP, Brightspot is built from the ground up as a secure, enterprise-grade CMS. The closed architecture minimizes risk by reducing exposure to the kinds of vulnerabilities that come with an open-source framework. With Brightspot, you benefit from:

  • Built-in security: Brightspot offers robust, out-of-the-box security features such as real-time threat detection, automatic patching and secure hosting — all managed by Brightspot's internal team.
  • Fewer external dependencies: Brightspot's comprehensive platform means you’re not relying on numerous third-party plugins or vendors, reducing the number of potential vulnerabilities in your tech stack.
  • Proactive security measures: Brightspot continuously monitors for threats and responds quickly to emerging vulnerabilities, offering enhanced protection compared to the more reactive patching process found in WordPress VIP's plugin ecosystem.

For organizations prioritizing security, Brightspot provides peace of mind, allowing your team to focus on creating and managing content without worrying about external vulnerabilities and constant patch management.

Why Brightspot is the right CMS for 2024 and beyond

WordPress VIP may provide some value as a service overlay for the open-source WordPress CMS, but its limitations — reliance on multiple vendors, lack of built-in advanced features and restricted multisite capabilities — make it less ideal for large-scale, fast-moving enterprises in 2024.

Brightspot offers a truly enterprise-grade CMS with an all-in-one solution that simplifies content management, accelerates workflows and delivers robust performance without the need for constant third-party support. When you choose Brightspot, you gain a partner invested in your long-term success, with the tools you need to thrive in an ever-changing digital environment.

Share

More from Brightspot

Related resources

Initiated in November 2021, the digital home for DispatchHealth got a major upgrade in January 2022. The DispatchHealth.com site was migrated off WordPress in less than two months.
Selecting the right CMS for your business is a pivotal decision, and one of the first strategic decisions to be made is whether to opt for an open source or proprietary CMS. This guide offers an in-depth comparison to help you make an informed decision.
Euromoney PLC manages one of Europe’s largest networks of B2B media brands. In 2020, Euromoney first partnered with Brightspot to consolidate its various publishing systems into one unified enterprise CMS that would allow for standardization and content sharing across properties.
Stuck with the limitations of a one-dimensional WordPress solution, Marriott International turned to Brightspot to invigorate corporate storytelling across its portfolio of 30 brands and more than 8,000 hotel properties around the world.
WordPress is one of the world's most popular CMS solutions for its affordability and accessibility. However, there are many WordPress alternatives, including Brightspot, that offer more powerful, more flexible and more extensible features.
Learn how Brightspot’s out-of-the-box CMS publishing tools transformed FedEx's ability to communicate with audiences around the world via its redesigned newsroom.
Let us give you a demo
Hear how Brightspot can turn your digital strategy goals into a reality and see how the lives of your content creators and developers will be changed using our platform.


Request Demo